AI content strategy: Sound human, perform better.
- Clara Masip Baugh
- Sep 29
- 4 min read
Updated: Oct 1
For years, digital marketing felt like a race to feed the algorithm: more content, more keywords, more volume. It was quantity over quality—serving the machine instead of the people on the other side of the screen.
Then AI arrived, promising to make content creation faster and easier than ever. But here’s the truth: AI on its own doesn’t create content that connects. Left unguided, it churns out words without context, voice, or depth.
Its real power only emerges when paired with human expertise—strategy, creativity, and judgment—to turn raw output into meaningful, memorable stories.
We’re not competing against machines. We’re working with them to be more human than ever before.
Table of contents
Writing has always been the tip of the iceberg
Great content doesn’t start with writing. It starts with strategy: deep audience insight, a clear brand voice, and a plan for what you want to say and why it matters.
Too many brands skip this work, rushing straight into content creation to save time or money. Tone-of-voice guidelines and brand positioning get treated as optional extras.
But in the era of AI, these foundations are non-negotiable. Without strategy, voice, and the right guidelines, AI-generated content is just generic noise flooding your channels—correct but invisible.
The stronger your strategy and brand voice, the more powerful your AI-assisted content becomes.
The algorithm evolved, and called our bluff
Search engines have grown up. From BERT to MUM, Google no longer rewards keyword stuffing or formulaic SEO tricks. It surfaces content with expertise, context, and real value.
Google’s March 2024 Core Update made it official: the old shortcuts don’t work anymore. It targeted low-quality, manipulative content, the kind algorithms and humans alike are learning to ignore.
And the data backs it up:
In a large-scale experiment across 744 articles, AI-generated content drove 5.44× less traffic than human-written pieces over five months. -NP Digital
Human-written articles ranked higher too: position 4.4 vs. 6.6 for AI content. -Reboot Online
Publishing large volumes of unedited, unoriginal (scaled) AI content risks reduced visibility in Search. -Google
But here’s the flip side: AI + human expertise performs far better. The issue isn’t AI itself, it’s using it without strategy or oversight.
AI speeds up what humans build
The stronger our tools get, the more valuable human creativity becomes.
AI isn’t a composer; it’s an amplifier. Feed it a vague prompt, and it churns out clichés. Feed it a strong strategy, distinct voice guidelines, and real expertise, and it multiplies your impact at speed.
The best use of AI is liberation: freeing writers from mechanical work, such as research, formatting, and variations, so they can focus on judgment, taste, and ideas. You can’t automate cultural relevance. You can’t ChatGPT yourself into brand differentiation.
You still need people with opinions, because engaging content isn’t a formula, it’s a feeling.
Pass the HUMAN test
Generative AI tools can produce drafts at incredible speed. But speed alone won't make your content resonate. That's why every AI draft needs to pass the HUMAN test—a five-point check that turns "robotic" into "on-brand":
Helpful: Does it answer the user's real question within the first lines?
Understandable: Is the language clear and concise, with jargon explained?
Memorable: Is there a vivid phrase or structure that feels uniquely you?
Accurate: Are facts, claims, and names verified? Are sources noted?
Necessary: Is anything redundant or decorative? Cut it.
The result? AI-assisted, human-perfected content that actually sounds like your brand, and not every other prompt on the internet.
AI content strategy: What it means for brands today
The data tells a clear story: as AI content proliferated, trust declined. 70% of consumers now struggle to trust online content because of generative AI's rise, and two-thirds worry about being scammed or deceived by AI-generated material.
Quality content is your brand's shield against noise and irrelevance. Without proper guidelines, without clear positioning, your AI tools produce faster garbage—digital pollution that damages your brand instead of building it.
The machines made quality non-negotiable.
Here's what winning looks like now:
Strategy isn't optional. You need to know who you are, what you stand for, and why anyone should care. The algorithm surfaces quality—you define what quality means for your brand.
Voice is your competitive advantage. In a world where everyone has access to the same AI tools, your unique perspective is the only thing that can't be commoditized.
Expertise actually matters. Google's E-E-A-T guidelines (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) aren't suggestions. The algorithm is checking credentials. Show your work. Have a point of view.
AI is the amplifier, not the composer. Use it to move faster, think bigger, test more. But strategic thinking, creative direction, editorial judgment—that's all you. That's the job.
Machines raised the bar. Humans keep it there.
AI has forced brands to embrace what marketers have long preached: investing strategically in voice, tone, and real value is no longer optional.
This isn't an AI-versus-human story. The future belongs to humans in the AI era—a partnership where human creativity, judgment, and vision shape technology's speed and scale.
The brands that succeed will craft fewer but better, deeply human stories—amplified by AI but created through human expertise.
Machines haven't taken our jobs. They've taken away excuses for generic, robotic content.
In this new era, there’s only one way forward: The future speaks human.
Looking for the right partner to optimise your content strategy and help you produce AI-assisted content the right way? Reach out and let's talk words!
Comments